Skip to main content
English French German Italian Spanish

1962 650SS – Drive Side Oil Leak

Forums

After fitting Thorspark electronic ignition and sorting out various electrical issues with the assistance of Al Osborn, I participated in the Jimmie Guthrie Memorial Run a couple of weeks ago.

Some 300 miles later, I had a significant oil leak on the drive side.

Removal of the primary chain case showed that a belt drive has been fitted.

I assumed that the crankshaft main seal was leaking as the chaincase should otherwise be dry.

Having removed the alternator and crank pulley the seal appears dry.

However, having removed the alternator basket thing, which is held on with 3nr countersunk socket head set screws, I find that the top and front holes in the crankcase appear to be blind holes, but the rear hole seems to be right through the crankcase - this may be the source of the leak.

Should these all be blind holes, or do I have an inappropriately modified case?

Any suggestions welcome please.

Alastair

Permalink

hello Alister - as far as I remember all the screw holes for securing the three alternator carrier bracket and the inner primary chain-case to the drive-side crankcase are through holes.  I usually secure them with a touch of stud lock into a degreased thread.  Good luck , Howard

Permalink

Thanks Howard

Not blind holes - just crank counterweights behind the hole position.

Tapped/ threaded holes for inner chaincase screws also pass through the crankcase.

I assume that all these fasteners need thead locking/ sealing agent to prevent passage of oil from crankcase to chaincase?

Is there any other way for oil to get into the chaincase which is where the oil leakage seemed to be coming from?

Permalink

Check that your crankcase pressure relief valve in the timing cover is working properly . They sometimes seem to seize up.  Howard

Howard,
Is that the oil pressure relief valve you are referring to, as opposed to the crankcase breather?
The breather on the left hand side is plumbed back up to the oil tank.

Permalink

Hi Alistair - No the crankcase pressure relief valve on a 650SS is the big nut at the bottom of the timing cover.  It allows oil to pass into the timing cover when the pressure gets high after wet-sumping or knackered piston rings.  It consists of two large nuts with a spring-loaded piston and often shims to adjust the pressure.  They piston often seizes into the barrel with age and little use.  When the pressure builds oil is soon output past the crankcase oil seal.  Cheers, Howard

Permalink

Did someone simply add unnecessary oil to the primary case?  They nearly all leak...which is why owners use belt drives.

Permalink

Actually, the pressure relief valve is located in the oil pump delivery line to limit maximum delivery pressure to the big-ends and rockers. Not there to deal with excessive crankcase pressure caused by wet-sumping or ring blow-by; that is the crankcase breather's role.

Permalink

...so no oil inside the chaincase?   Didn't you report oil coming from the chaincase?  If so, it's either from the engine (but the oil seal is good) or gearbox or someone has put it in there.  Oil can come along the actuator rod hole, but not a lot unless the gearbox is massively overfilled.

Permalink

You're quite correct Andrew however the timed-breather for the crankcase barely copes with the early 500cc engines.  If something happens to cause a sudden onset of excess oil into the timing cover it can increase the volume of oil in the crankcase and so can become over-pressurised and oil can escape wherever it can on a downstroke of the pistons.  Having the breather piped back into the oil tank, like the 650SS and Atlas, did not cure the breathing problem.  It made another item susceptible to leaks.   If you have a good look around a race prepared pre-Commando twin power unit you will see the lengths to which people are driven with external tubes everywhere to get the engine breathing properly.  Good luck, howard   

Permalink

Still haemorrhaging oil from primary drive case.
It is a belt drive and has no oil fill to the primary case, so should remain dry.
The leak appears to be coming from the case cover joint, so oil is getting from the crankcase through the inner chaincase into the primary drive area. There is no evidence of significant oil covering to the outside of the alloy crankcase itself. Some pictures are attached.
I think I will need to resort to some kind of sealant – up till now I have been using a thread locking/ sealing compound which sets hard.
Is there a recommendation for this?
Thanks in advance for any assistance.
Alastair
 

Permalink

Hi,

In some of your recent photos,  it looks like either the seal isn't fully home, or the crank has been shimmed towards the timing side a bit too much? 

is the seal lip actually running on the full circle of the mainshaft, or is it running across the keyway?

Also,check for any 'burrs' on the mainshaft opposite the key slot - if the sprocket has been tightened and the key is too high/slot in sprocket too small, it is possible to tighten the retainer nut and throw up a burr on the crank. 

Regards, 

George 

Permalink

The inner cover and alternator housing fixings are well known for leaking crankcase oil into the primary area.

Permalink

I know what you mean George, but there is no evidence of oil in that area.

The bike was new to me at the beginning of the year, so I don't know how it was set up when built.

Any sealant type and application methodology recommendations Robert?

Permalink

The crankshaft oil seal looks in the correct position but the sprocket key does look dangerously close to the seal itself.  How much crankshaft play is there? The oil pump worm will push the crankshaft sideways,  especially if there are two roller crankshaft bearings that have not been shimmed up correctly. More than 20 thou play is going to cause problems.

The oil seal looks like  the type with a poor reputation for wearing quickly and not doing its job properly. Also with a dry belt primary drive system, the inner seal lip does not get lubricated so well and may wear faster.  

The crankcase photo shows some damage in the lower section. Is that a crack across the flange in photo IMG_2421.JPG. and a line of pin holes lower down? This does not look so healthy and possibly worth investing in a tube of  JB Weld.

Permalink

No pin holes or cracks in case.

It does seem to have been a little beaten up over the last 60-odd years, but the pics look worse than the reality.

The key is very close to the seal but not touching - I may grind a little off the inboard end to be sure.

No transverse movement of crank.

Best sealant for screws into cases?

Permalink

Wellseal is a low viscosity sealant that never sets hard. You can use it on metal to metal joints, gaskets and smear it on threads before fitting screws or studs. Has always worked perfectly for me.

Permalink

Check the faces for flatness. The leftover blue sealant (Hylomar?) on the chaincase and engine in the region of the bolt holes tells me that there is some thing not flat. A close look at the photo showing the damage to the lower part of the gasket face shows what looks like a porous weld. Judicious use of RTV, smearing it over the damaged areas and on the gasket on assembly might stop the leak. Improve the crankcase breathing, the timed breather is pathetic.   Edit. A close look at photo 2419 shows what looks like a crack in the case, the edge of the case that locates the alternator basket has probably been built up with weld to help locate the basket. You need to dye penetrate test the case in that area    

Permalink

Depends on how you view modifications. To fit a crankcase reed valve breather either buy the NYC reed breather kit, (expensive but no permanent mods) Or somehow fit an inexpensive reed valve unit from an XS650 or similar (search for 125 egr valve on ebay etc) The problem being is getting the vent pipe connection to the crankcase. 
Personally i would do away with the timed breather and tap into where the timed breather pipe exits the crankcase, increasing the ID of the drillway to approx 10mm. and directly connected it to the crankcase void (not going through the cam) Unfortunately this means an engine strip, but is the most un-intrusive way of getting a large bore vent connection to the crankcase. An engine strip anyway would be a good idea, if nothing else it will be a good check on what ever work has been done in the past. If you do strip the engine, be prepared for whatever horrors might, and probably do, exist inside.
Sorry if i sound like a pessimist but having dealt with bikes that have 'just been restored' etc I find that no end of bodges, sloppy work, fitting wrong bits and tall tales etc are just part and parcel of the old bike scene.
The latest 'bodge' i saw was on a little Ducati at Squires cafe last Thursday evening. Its front brake cable was fitted with a screw on nipple at the drum lever.....an accident waiting to happen

Permalink

The blue stuff is the thread locking/ sealing material I used for the 6nr set screws into the crankcase – 3nr for inner chaincase and 3nr for alternator housing. Picture attached. This sets hard – it must have oozed out a little bit which is the deposit you can see in the images. It is a very thin hard film which flakes off cleanly.
The thickened disc of the crankcase to locate the alternator basket/ housing seems unlikely to be cracked/ leak/ welded as presumably this is the thickest portion of the casting?
Image attached without inner chaincase.
I will judiciously apply sealant to screw threads and mating faces to each side of gasket and reassemble.
I really don’t understand why the faces look so beaten up – in reality, the depth of marks is not particularly apparent to the touch. I have never worked with JB Weld (High Heat) before, but may try to apply a light coating and file/ sand back to original metal using a flat block before re-assembly.
A complete rebuild is not possible right now as I am heading to the Manx next month on the bike and have too much other stuff going on at the moment.
 

Permalink

Ordering some parts from RGM this evening - some "whilst you are in there" stuff and came across a crankshaft drive side woodruff key with milled ends - 067595.

Dimensions match mine, except the length is 17.5mm - mine is 20.95mm.

Should provide a bit more clearance from the seal, although I don't think that is the problem.

Fitting new pressure relief valve piston, spring & shims together with new oil pump to case seal and tacho drive gasket whilst the timing cover is off. Again, probably not the problem, but worth the peace of mind.

Should all arrive with the Wellseal & JB Weld for the weekend and another attempt at oil-tightness.

Permalink

A close look at photo 2416 clearly shows a ring of weld all the way round the alternator basket spigot. Where the weld has been machined off also shows pinholes/porosity. This is indicative of some sort of catastrophic failure in the past, and somebodies effort to repair said damage.     A thorough degrease and smear RTV over all the affected area, might stop the oil seeping through the case. Buy a big tube of RTV, Wynns black gasket RTV is good 

Permalink

Grasped the nettle last night and made a start.
I used a large cable tie to make a tourniquet sleeve and lined it with pvc tape to act as a release agent.
Mixed a small quantity of JB Weld High Temp and applied it carefully (for me anyway) to the affected area of seemingly poor, possibly porous weld.
Removed the cable tie this morning and it looks reasonably good.
I will leave it for another 24 hours or so to fully cure before fitting the alternator basket and commencing reassembly with liberal gasket sealant.
New woodruff key leaves a little bit more clearance to the oil seal.
 

Permalink

Comparing photo 2419 against the Repair 2 & 3 photos looks to show the epoxy has fallen away from the area where the case looks to be cracked. Did you thoroughly degrease the case to the point of rubbing the area with a clean bit of kitchen roll shows NO dirt/oil? The oil held in the crack will seep out and it is almost impossible to clean out, It can be done but takes some effort.    

Permalink

I will go over it with a dremel and make the crack a little deeper to get more surface area for adhesion

Permalink

I finally got the time to put the primary drive side back together with ample RTV sealant on all mating surfaces, around all fixing holes and on the threads of the fixings themselves.
I left the bike for 24 hours to let everything cure properly.
Went for a 20 minute run yesterday to get petrol and everything was dry when I got back.
However, a couple of hours later there was a evidence of a small amount of oil leakage below the primary chaincase.
Much better, but no cigar!
Off to MGP next week, so it will just have to do for now. I'm sure they sell oil over there.

Permalink

Just to close off this thread, we had a successful trip to the island last week with many miles completed in atrocious weather.

Unfortunately, on the return journey from Heysham back to Scotland, the bike failed to proceed at Kendal.

By the sound of the failure episode, I think probably top end related. Got home 11 hours later courtesy of the AA.

Now starting to collect the parts for a complete rebuild - first purchase made yesterday: a good looking pair of crankcases from Norvil.

I may start a new strip down/ rebuild thread if that would attract sage advice of do's/ dont's from those more experienced on here.

Permalink

Hello again Alistair - cases look nice. I wonder why the intermediate spindle is missing - they are usually very tight fit.  I'd say they are from 66 or later.   Use new bushes and studs from a reputable supplier.  Cheers for now, Howard

Permalink

Thanks Howard - will do.

Permalink

Hi Peter,   your comment on a bodge on a Ducati single is incorrect !, they came like that from the factory. a similar detail also  on the clutch cable. I have never had one fail ,they  use a heavy duty cable and being so light a bike it just works. Looks a bit naff though !.

 



© 2024 Norton Owners Club Website by 2Toucans