My speedo seems to be knackered, does anyone have any experience of the cheap reproduction ones .... like one of these, I'm concerned about reliability than originality?
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/SPEEDO-0-80-MPH-BLACK-FACE-65-MM-BEZEL-BLACK-FACE-SMITHS-TYPE-BRAND-NEW-/302129072968?hash=item46584bcb48:g:B5wAAOSwvg9XbAB7
Previously Dan Field wrote…
- Log in to post comments
These certainly look prett…
These certainly look pretty similar to the black faced Smiths clock fitted from 1959 to 1963. Yours presumably is the later grey faced one. I would have two questions to ask the seller;
(1) the cable fitting at the back of the speedo appears to be different to the original Smiths. So a replacement speedo cable is presumably needed as well. can he supply this? (2) What number is the cable turns - the original Jubilee/Navigator was 1600 and this number is marked on the face of the speedo. So what is the TPM for this speedo?- it isn't shown on the face. Smiths speedos and drive gearboxes did vary from bike to bike so are not always a direct swop- A BSA bantam speedo will not be accurate if fitted to a Jubilee. You might have to change the speedo drive (2 to 1 I think on the Jubilee) on the rear hub to match the new speedo otherwise you could have a seriously inaccurate speedo.
Patrick
- Log in to post comments
Try this guy. He repairs t…
Try this guy. He repairs them. I used him about ten years ago and he's still in business so he must be doing a reasonable job.
www.chronometricspeedos.co.uk
- Log in to post comments
Or here: http://www.magnet…
Or here:
http://www.magnetic-speedometer-repair.com/
http://www.magnetic-speedometer-repair.com/the-odomerter.php
A How-to to disassemble it.
Once I restored an Italian Gilera 150cc which also had a Smith speedo. I cleaned up the speedo myself an I guess I have some surplus parts for it also.
How did you test the speedo?
Attachments
Gilera%20220.jpg
Gilera%20221.jpg
noc-ch
- Log in to post comments
Previously Dan Field wrote…
Previously Dan Field wrote:
My speedo seems to be knackered, does anyone have any experience of the cheap reproduction ones .... like one of these, I'm concerned about reliability than originality?
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/SPEEDO-0-80-MPH-BLACK-FACE-65-MM-BEZEL-BLACK-FACE-SMITHS-TYPE-BRAND-NEW-/302129072968?hash=item46584bcb48:g:B5wAAOSwvg9XbAB7
I got one from India about a couple of years ago for my 1965 Electra.It was cheap fitted and worked well. I made the mistake of packing the drive box with grease this forced it up the cable into the speedo head this stopped it working properly. I took it apart put petrol into the speedo to wash it out with a good shaking. I took it for a test ride yesterday surprise it worked perfect. Also I bought one for my big 4 this looks and fits ok but the drive is different I still have to get around to sorting it out. Bryon
- Log in to post comments
Previously Ulrich Hoffmann…
Previously Ulrich Hoffmann wrote:
Or here:
http://www.magnetic-speedometer-repair.com/
http://www.magnetic-speedometer-repair.com/the-odomerter.php
A How-to to disassemble it.
Once I restored an Italian Gilera 150cc which also had a Smith speedo. I cleaned up the speedo myself an I guess I have some surplus parts for it also.
How did you test the speed
nothing scientific, it just wobbled between 0 and 10 wouldn't go above 10mph. Nothing to lose taking it apart I guess!
- Log in to post comments
Hi Dan....if the replaceme…
Hi Dan....if the replacement is for a heavy weight Norton this might be more similar in looks:
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/VINTAGE-SMITHS-BLACK-SPEEDOMETER-BSA-ENFIELD-NORTON-0-120-MPH-REPLICA-With-CABLE-/162068255433?hash=item25bc0552c9:g:Ky0AAOSwHJhXNEs1
These Indian speedos are of course the "Magnetic" type
I have a MPH Indian speedo on my Enfield bullet (80MPH) and they work nicely , with smooth action and reliable. Only trouble is they are usually very optimistic in their reading but this shouldn't cause problems apart from holding traffic up behind you if you take them too seriously.....Les
NB...This shop was selling the speedo itself for a remarkably low £15 (inc postage) without cable so enquire if they still have some (if you want one that is) .....sorry but I bought the last one they had currently!....
OOPS....Oh Dear.....just noticed the speedo you wanted was for a lightweight Norton....but I'll leave my reply on here as it might be of use to other members for their heavyweight bikes....but then again I might be accused of "Hijacking"........please let me know......
- Log in to post comments
Dan before taking it apart…
Dan before taking it apart test the speedo by running it up in a reversible electric drill. It turns anti-clock. I use a nail with the head cut off in the drill chuck to drive it. The drive gear on the back wheel can also give trouble by stripping it's gears. So it's not always the speedo which is faulty.
The chrome rim on the Smiths 100 mph black faced speedo is very difficult to remove and even more of a problem to put back on. Maybe Ulrich or Ian Easton can give you some tips on this as both have done this before. I damaged the rim on the only one I have ever taken apart -that was years ago and very few of the speedo repair people would even think of undertaking the fitting of a new rim as they all said that special equipment was needed for these "roll-on" rims.
Patrick
- Log in to post comments
Patrick, you were right it…
Patrick, you were right it's the rear wheel gearbox that's stripped its gears! it seems it's the drive wheel that is stripped, the worm looks ok. In my spares box I have a spare gearbox with a good drive wheel but no worm drive. So if I want to swap the worm dive into the other box how do these things come apart ?! is the brass rounded end pressed in?
Failing that has anyone fitted one of those Royal Enfield ones with a 5/8th /16mm centre, which is a bit too big for the jubilees 9/16th? /14.5mm axle?
Found this which helps:http://www.accessnorton.com/smiths-speedometer-drive-rebuild-explained-t16163.html
Cheers Dan
- Log in to post comments
Another how-to-link to the…
Another how-to-link to the black forum:
http://www.accessnorton.com/installing-smith-instrument-bezel-t7487.html
On my Gilera Smiths speedo I used a new chrome ring. The old one broke during disassembling the gauge. The new one was rolled on by a local Kienzle speedo service firm which unfortunatly closed down.
- Log in to post comments
Just received a similar 2…
Just received a similar 2 1/2" speedo for a late Bantam...Supplier was based in India....As expected quality not too good as bezel (rim) is dented. The box was not damaged and the item wrapped in thick polystyrene so impossible to sustain damage in transit....it's obvious the item was sent out with the dent already in it.... So now I am wasting time with it, photographing it and sending messages and will probably have to take it to the Post office to return the thing.... You really have to be careful with Indian suppliers, they are always chancing their luck hoping you'll accept poor quality items...Luckily, one has good backup on Ebay and you're last resort is giving negative feedback.
Les
- Log in to post comments
Some Indian suppliers are…
Some Indian suppliers are extremely good, produce well engineered products and show a great of respect to their customers in my experience. So not everyone should be tarred with the same brush.
- Log in to post comments
The one on eBay I was eyeb…
The one on eBay I was eyeballing was only a tenner http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/SMITHS-SPEEDO-DRIVE-ROYAL-ENFIELD-BSA-NORTON-ETC-BRAND-NEW-/311628501041?hash=item488e819031:g:6QwAAOSwajVUNO69
to be honest the only problem I've had with Indian stuff was with a pair of handle bars mounts, one was badly made and had an air pocket in the casting which weakened the threads. The guy was really apologetic and quickly sent me another pair so now I have a spare!
Ive been tinkering all morning and finally got the spigot out of the end of the damaged drive unit and dismantled it , pics to follow. As expected the drive pinion was knackered, but the one in my other one seems to be ok, so as soon as the Sunday lunch has gone down I'll try and put it all back together...... I'm cautiously optimistic!
- Log in to post comments
Dan: Have you checked your…
Dan:
Have you checked your speedometer drive cable? Mine acted similar to yours. The broken inner was rubbing ends and making the head twitch like you described.
Mike
- Log in to post comments
It was def the speedo driv…
It was def the speedo drive the drive pinion has a big groove worn down the centre, after much bashing I got it apart and fitted the worm drive into a S/h I had without the worm. It goes together easier than it come apart. It seems to work ok although it has a tight spot which I hope will "run in". The cable was new. I'll try it out when it's warmer in the garage and report back.
- Log in to post comments
Good news is having rebuil…
Good news is having rebuilt the drive the speedo now works as it should .... for the time being at least! So I have a spare £20 repo speedo I didn't need! Still might put it on the ES2 trials.
Dan
- Log in to post comments
Previously Dan Field wrote:
I've had a tacho on the bsa, very cheap, sent from India, it works fine
Let me know how well it fits