The compression is low on my 1959 Model 50. Having read an article on improving the performance of a Model 50 by Mike Pemberton in the NOC magazine I have decided to investigate the valve timing in pursuit of a solution. However, I am confused. All the timing marks are aligned (see attached photograph) and in the article Mike suggests that one tooth advance on the inlet cam should (may) give me the inlet valve opening, or just starting to open, at 31 degrees BTDC. However, with the marks aligned the piston is on top dead centre and surely the valves should be closed for the combustion stroke. So, I assume that I should be testing for the valve to be opening at top dead centre when the fuel/air mixture is being drawn into the cylinder ? What is the best way to determine the valve is beginning to open ?
Mike
Improving performance
- Log in to post comments
Model 50 Valve Timing continued.
Hi Richard,
Thanks for your full response. My engine has been rebored, new piston, new rings, new valve guides and valves lapped in. It has a new head gasket and has been leak tested. It still is low on compression and that is why I have arrived at this point of questioning the valve timing, to some extent fuelled by Mike Pemberton's article to which I referred earlier.
With tappets adjusted correctly there was little resistance when kicking over. Taking a friend's advice I slackened off the inlet tappet leaving a big gap. This markedly improved the compression and the engine was considerably more difficult to kick over (I didn't run it like this). The motive behind this test was that by slackening off of the tappet it had the effect of causing the valve to open slightly later. It is this that had led me into considering the valve timing. Am I correct in this assumption ? If so, surely the timing correction I am considering i.e. ensuring the valve opens at 30 degrees BTDC, will exacerbate the problem ? As you can tell, I am confused.
My problem now is how to accurately detect the initial opening of the inlet valve. Nothing I've tried so far is precise enough.
The bottom line to all this is that after a complete rebuild my bike has low compression and commensurately poor performance !
Mike
- Log in to post comments
Valve is open.
Mike,
You have written that following a top end rebuild your bike has very low compression, but when you loosened the tappet adjuster, it had good compression.
If this is correct, then you have not adjusted the tappets correctly. One of the valves is slightly open because the tappet clearance is too tight.
On our singles there is no actual tappet clearance gap, the tappet clearance is adjusted correctly when you can turn the pushrod with your fingers but not have any up and down movement.
Maybe your fingers are too strong!
Try and back the tappet adjuster off until there is just discernable up and down movement in the pushrods AFTER YOU HAVE TIGHENED THE LOCKNUTS.
It takes ages for me to get mine 'just right' and often I feel you need 3 hands to do it properly!
Don Anson
Melbourne
- Log in to post comments
Valve timing is complex. …
Valve timing is complex. The inlet should start to open at around 30 degrees before tdc on the inlet stroke , the timing is sometimes found to be well out on these motors so a bit of experimenting can wake the engine up. Do some more reading up on the subject .
- Log in to post comments
Setting the cam by when it…
Setting the cam by when it starts to open is too hard to be precise. The crank moves a long way because of the gradual ramp on the cam. I've always gone by valves rocking (on a single cam engine) or full lift.
Full lift inlet cam, on your engine - from the figures given above - is 110 degrees after TDC on the non compression stroke. People say you can't find the top of the cam but of course you can - if you can use a dial gauge - in fact some performance camshaft suppliers recommend using the full lift figure as the most accurate way of dialling a cam in.
Try it !
- Log in to post comments
More on M50 Valve Timing
Terry,
Thank you for this suggestion. I'll try to check that the valve is fully open at 110 degrees after TDC. My timing disc is split into four sets of 90 degrees. So I guess I am looking for 70 degrees ? i.e. 90 degrees after plus another 20 degrees counting back to BDC at zero.
So TDC, 10, 20, 30, 40, 50, 60, 70, 80, 90, 80, 70
Mike
- Log in to post comments
Re-cap on setting inlet valve timing on Model 50
Following up on the previous correspondence on this issue this is the test I'm going to make:
On the non compression stroke find TDC. Using a dial gauge rotate the engine back and forth until the top of the cam is identified. This should be at 70 deg. on the timing disc i.e. 110 deg. after TDC.
Now rotate the engine backwards 140 deg. If the valve timing is correct the pointer on the timing disc should now be at 30 deg, BTDC or thereabouts. If it is between 10 and 20 deg. then the inlet valve timing is wrong and should be correctable by moving the inlet timing gear one tooth clockwise. Then, having made this change, the checking procedure can be repeated and I should find the inlet valve is now starting to open at between 25 and 30 deg. BTDC.
Is this correct ?
Mike
- Log in to post comments
If you have low compression.....
do a leakdown test to locate your leakage. Cam timing is a wild goose chase.
- Log in to post comments
You have it, from TDC, ( non…
You have it, from TDC, ( non compression stroke), engine rotated the normal firing direction of course, 110 degrees later ,the inlet lobe should be fully open, and, as you say, should then be at the 70 mark. Full open checked by rotating back and forth, preferably with the dial gauge on, but for a rough check, it's an easy visual check anyway.
110 is half way between inlet opening at 30 BTDC and closing at 70 after ABDC. It simply avoids the slow lift movements at beginning and end. Easy to work out from any cam spec figures.
I take it that the figures Richard Cornish quoted are correct. ( I don't have any information about the singles ).
Have a go Mike ! it costs nothing and it's all part of the fun.
- Log in to post comments
Just one thing when checking…
Just one thing when checking compression, fully open the throttle, if it can’t get air in, it won’t compress. Makes a big difference on mine.
- Log in to post comments
Valve timing.
Hi Mike,
I think your problem here is the quietening ramps as when the engine is cold, these extend the timing period to an artificial amount. When the engine gets hot the barrel and head expand much more than the push-rods and this corrects the situation. Set the push-rods with the engine cold on TDC of the firing stroke the turn the top cup hexagon back a 1/2 turn on both push-rods, which is .019" and should eliminate the ramps issue for setting purposes. Try Terry's method and see how the opening and closing points look like. The numbers might read lower, for instance 25 - 65, but as long as you have the same difference either side it should be O.K. When you re-set the tappet clearance, you will still have the same issue with low compression until the engine gets up to full temperature. When the bike is run in , it should be good for 75mph, but rember it's a 350 in a 600 sized bike.
- Log in to post comments
Er, sort of - the first…
Er, sort of - the first paragraph would be better stated : set the piston at TDC on the non compression stroke and the timing disc also at TDC. Then, rotate the engine forwards a total of 110 deg. At that, the inlet valve cam lobe should be at max. You can then work the crank back and forth a few degrees to see if it is at the peak, or use a DTI.
The rest , your experiments to check it all out , fine, do it !, experiment and satisfy yourself all good ( or otherwise ). It will be something either eliminated or sorted.
You're welcome to PM me if you need to, but I think you have it sussed out already, tell us what you find .Are those engines separate cams for in and ex ? If so, work out the peak lift for the ex and check that too. Same principle.
- Log in to post comments
Valve timing.
Hi Mike,
This is getting a bit confused, the total cam opening period is 280 degrees of CRANKSHAFT rotation. Set the piston at TDC on the induction stroke and then turn the engine FORWARD 110 degrees, which is just over half-way down the stroke, then fit the inlet cam at it's maximum lift. Turn the engine forward again so the piston goes down to BDC and then comes up a third of the stoke where it should be just closed at 70 after BDC. To set the exhaust cam, go to the same TDC and turn the engine BACKWARDS 110 which is just over halfway down the stroke. Fit the exhaust cam at maximum lift. Turn the engine backwards 140 down past BDC and a third of the way up the other side to 70 before BDC when the exhaust should just be ready to open when the engine goes forward. If you find your 90 degree disc confusing mark top and bottom centres and then mark the complete opening ark of each valve in 2 different colours. All this should result in both valves being open an equal amount at TDC which is the valve overlap.
- Log in to post comments
M50 Valve Timing - Thanks for help and advice
All who have contributed,
Valve timing all sorted. Bike now back together with, what seems like, the right level of compression. Runs in the garage - now for the road test.
Thanks to all.
Mike
- Log in to post comments
4 degrees before TDC
for the equal lift point is what I read in articles about cam timing.
- Log in to post comments
A quick check......
... to see if the valve timing is correct (not 1 tooth out!): At TDC on the non-ignition stroke, the inlet and exhaust valves should be nearly equally open. If one is much more open than the other, there is a problem.
- Log in to post comments
Equal lift point on Mikes'…
Equal lift point on Mikes' M50 is TDC.
Inlet opens 30 BTDC, exhaust closes 30 ATDC.
Overlap centre, ie "valves rocking ", thus has to be TDC, but it's true many engines do have the overlap point a few degrees before.
Valves rocking is the old way of setting a camshaft in, without knowledge of the timing figures.
This was all explained to me in 1967 by an old hand lorry mechanic , I was very dubious and wanted to get a degree disc," nah, it'll be reet lad ".
And it was.
- Log in to post comments
Hi Mike,
If the compression is low, it is likely there is an issue with the condition of the bore/piston/rings, valve seating/tappet clearance, head joint or tight valve lifter cable. You need to check all these out before you try changing the valve timing. As a general test, you should be able to stand on the kick start for a couple of seconds before over-coming the compression, and the bike should have a top speed of at least 70mph in normal conditions.
Your photo looks like you are on TDC with both valves on equal over-lap, which is correct. To check, set the timing disc pointer at zero and then turn the crankshaft backwards 30 degrees and the inlet tappet should just be on the point of lifting when you turn the crankshaft forward. Remember the cam-wheels turn the opposite rotation to the crankshaft. If you advance the cam-wheel by one tooth, this equals 9 degrees and may advance the opening too much, so anything more than 25 degrees should be left alone. If you can find an earlier half-time pinnion they have 3 unequal key slots for more precise timing. The ideal timing for your engine will be inlet open 30 BTDC, close 70 ABDC, exhaust open 70 BBDC, close 30 ATDC. The later cams have a gradual pre and post open period profile for less mechanical noise, so you will have to allow for this when determining the effective opening point.
P.S.
Re - Robert's post. If you can find a copy, "Tuning for Speed" by Phil Irving is an invaluable book to understand the fundamental dynamics of valve timing.