Hi, I'm new to Commando's and I've a Mk 1 850, I noticed oil mist from the 2 bolts at the front of the gearbox that are quite inaccessible but managed to get a spanner on them to nip them up only to find it feels like they're changing the gears upon turning the bolts !!!! what's going on and what's the worst can happen ???
David, Those two bolts…
- Log in to post comments
Hi Andy, thanks for your…
Hi Andy, thanks for your reply, so no damage or issues with me touching them ? and gear change sequence isn't altered ? thanks Dave
- Log in to post comments
Dave, you will be okay, as…
Dave, you will be okay, as as the gear change sequencing can only be altered with the gearbox inner cover removed. You are are just selecting gears by moving the camplate with the bolt. Andy
- Log in to post comments
Andy you're a star, thanks…
Andy you're a star, thanks for answering the question , another forum's attitude was to tell me to ''get a manual'' and stop ''fiddling with bolts'' not really helping at all !!!!!!
- Log in to post comments
You really should get a…
You really should get a manual anyway - you’ll need it
john
- Log in to post comments
Thanks John for not…
Thanks John for not answering the question, obviously you didn't know either, or you would of been kind enough to be helpful, at least there's now two more of us who know what these bolts are for.
- Log in to post comments
I'm pretty sure John didn't…
I'm pretty sure John didn't answer the question because the question had already been answered, so why be rude to him? We are all prepared to help each other. "There's no such thing as a silly question...only a silly answer". But, as John quite rightly says...you should do yourself a favour and get a manual. Looking after a 40 plus year old Norton is not the same as relying on your local car dealer to service a new Nissan.
- Log in to post comments
Like you said , he didn't…
Like you said , he didn't answer the question, but then again neither did you............
I treated his remark as him trying to be funny or even sarcastic, I think it's rude and ignorant to suggest that I would even contemplate working on any machine without having a manual, in this case, Haynes, Norman White's excellent book, Chris Rooke's restoration book and extensive ''googling'', but still couldn't the find the answer, so I asked the question on this forum and only one person could give me the correct answer.
- Log in to post comments
All right...but I don't…
All right...but I don't think he meant to be rude. You are correct that it's not easy to find good drawings of lots of parts and I've not seen a section through that detail. The external nut is pretty much a continuation of the design from the Sturmey Archer box fom the late 1920's, when the cam plate was operated by an external lever onto effectively the same point. On later bakes the change mechanism all went inside the box. But, if you could add lever to the nut (and reach it somehow) you should be able to use it to change gear....might be handy if you lose the brake positive stop on the road. Put a spanner on it to find a gear, bump start in 3rd, and rude home slowly on the clutch? I couldn't do it myself but no doubt there are heroes about who can bump start an 850 Commando.
It's usually so filthy down there on my bikes that I'd never be able to tell if that point is leaking or not. I think the earlier Doll's Head box has a cork washer, but oil often leaked from all sorst of mysterious places on earlier bikes. I've no idea when an o ring arrived.
O rings are not close to ideal for rotation. Lip seals are far better. I don't know if the 850 has any. But RGM and others sell X rings to replace the O rings on the kick-start and gear change levers, and they do a much better job of keeping the outside of the box clean. Perhaps a keen owner might fit one on the nut/shaft you are looking at. I'd prefer to ride it but if you do work on the box in the future it might be worth considering.
- Log in to post comments
Cheers David, really…
Cheers David, really appreciate your answer to the question.
- Log in to post comments
Haynes and White are not to blame
Well, I think in this case at least the Haynes manual and Norman White's book are not to blame, perhaps it would pay if you had another read/look.
In the Haynes copy I have:
Page 54 - Chapter 2, paragraph 3, section 5:
describes removal of the two bolts that secure camplate and quadrant.
Page 59 - Chapter 10, paragraph 10, sections 3 and 5:
describes refitting the same bolts.
Page 56 - Fig. 2.2 Gear cluster and gearbox shell
shows the bolts (26), the washers (27) and the O-rings (25)
In the copy of the White book I have, there is enough text and pictures in chapter 9 - transmission that give clues about these bolts.
On internet, you may have missed Old Britts fine write-up
- Log in to post comments
David,
Those two bolts retain the gear change selector camplate and quadrant spindles, which is why you are noticing gears changing when you apply torque to them. Both have an o-ring seal behind the bolt washer and these may need replacing if oil is getting past.
Andy