This is prompted by Neil Wyatt's comment regarding Esso Supreme Synergy 99 super unleaded here:https://www.nortonownersclub.org/comment/90888#comment-90888 (last comment as I write)
This is what Esso say (https://www.esso.co.uk/en-gb/fuels):
"Although our pumps have E5 labels on them, our Synergy Supreme+ 99 is ethanol-free (except, due to technical supply reasons, in Devon, Cornwall, North Wales, North England and Scotland). Legislation requires us to place E5 labels on pumps that dispense unleaded petrol with ‘up to 5% ethanol’, including those that contain no ethanol."
It's been the case for some time that E5 super unleaded supplied from the Stanlow refinery contains ethanol. This applies to all fuel brands including Shell V-Power, Tesco Momentum etc. It's all the same. So you might as well fill up where ever is cheapest and most convenient.
And Stanlow supplies North Wales and most of North West England. Don't know how far it extends into the North East, but it might be everywhere north of Birmingham. If your super unleaded is supplied from Fawley, i.e. South East England it could well be that it doesn't contain ethanol.
But rather than just spout off I though I'd demonstrate this to be true so I bought a couple of litres of Esso Synergy Supreme+ 99 from just outside Chester on the Northwich road. After performing the test below, I conclude it contains around 4% ethanol. I'll take a jerry can with me next time I go to Birmingham and do the same test. But the takeaway has to be that if it's important to you to know whether your petrol contains ethanol then do a test.
It would be interesting to know what results people around the country are getting.
- Take a clear/translucent bottle with straight sides, a 2 litre fizzy drinks bottle is used here, and fill with tap water to a little under half way - 800ml here.
- Place on a level surface and mark the level of the water. Sight to the bottom of the meniscus to counter surface tension effects.
- Add roughly the same amount of petrol. The precise amount is not important, only that the upper level remains within the cylindrical part of the bottle. And mark that level. Measure the height of the petrol layer and note down.
- Screw on the top and vigourously shake the bottle. Left long enough the ethanol will migrate into the water anyway but thorough mixing of petrol and water speeds things up by increasing the contact surface.
- Allow to settle. Doesn't take long for ethanol content to become apparent but leaving overnight is ideal.
- Measure the height of the bottom of the petrol layer above the marked line. Any ethanol will have tranfered from the petrol into the water, the boundary between water and petrol moving up in proportion to the ethanol content.
Here, the original height of the petrol layer was 105mm and the boundary moved up by 4mm when settled. Therefore the petrol contained 4% enthanol.
The petrol layer in the bottle is now, to all intents and purposes, ethanol free. It can be drawn off, carefully, and used as normal. Ethanol is an octane booster so this petrol will be a significantly lower octane, at a guess, something around 95RON. Adding your favourite octane booster, e.g. http://tetraboost.com/tetraboost-e-guard-15 , can result in good old 4*. Not really practical for everyday but for occassional use or a racing bike with a fibreglass tank it might be worth the trouble. Then again, you could ask a friendly private plane owner to get you some avgas. Or buy a drum of Gulf Classic Fuel https://gulf-racefuels.co.uk/products (bottom of page).
More Info
I managed an Asda petrol station in the north Portsmouth area until recently. The fuels were always supplied by Esso but curiously never came from Fawley. This I never understood as it seemed bonkers to send tankers 200 miles when there was a refinery just 40 miles along the coast.
My petrol station only sold basic Unleaded and Diesel but there were two Esso and a single Shell garage, within a 5 mile radius, all selling Super Unleaded with E5 stickers on the pumps and other labels mentioning zero Ethanol. For reasons that could not be explained by the Esso station staff.......at one garage the petrol was labelled as 97 Ron and at the other it was 99 Ron.
- Log in to post comments
I ceased to take petrol…
I ceased to take petrol station staff seriously after I was refused sand to treat a couple of gallons of gas that lay under my car , apparently they don’t like mess .
- Log in to post comments
Ethanol
Hi Philip,
I'm told old that all fuel up to 5% % has to have ab E5 sticker on it. At Esso the trick is in the red label on the pump.
Different fuel, same confusion. We used to have a train carrying coal direct out of the ground to Drax power station about 3 miles away. But now at tremendous cost we have ships bringing wood pellets over the Atlantic. (And then by road)
All I know is the fuel I use is about 99.9% E Zero. I'll settle for that.
- Log in to post comments
Red label Neil, 'cos you…
Red label Neil, 'cos you told me to look out for it. I'll double check, maybe take a photo so we can compare. But my understanding from Esso's web page is that red means E5 super unleaded, blue means E10 regular unleaded.
As for where ethanol is added, it's at the refinery; whatever's in the tanker when it leaves the gate is what you put in your tank*. Since ethanol boosts octane number, the refinery can use a lower cost base grade of petrol before adding ethanol to bring the octane rating up to the required level. This will be a carefully controlled process to ensure a consistent grade with no "give away". They will calculate whether the cost of improving the octane by power forming is greater than the cost (to them) of adding ethanol. Stanlow seems to have decided that ethanol is cheaper.
* except for the small number of places selling 4*; they mix in some TetraBoost at the fuel station.
- Log in to post comments
Ethanol. Red or Blue
OK, Stan,
I have found a picture With the red label clearly showing with the blue label clearly on the pump next to it. I'd need to find the SD card to send it. So like you I'll take another picture on my next visit. I also have an e-mail, one of many stating that Esso has no intention of adding ethanol to its Super unleaded in the E free zones.
Now, if I were to go 28 miles North West to Ripon the Super unleaded carries a blue label (E zone) but less than 10 miles East into Harrogate we are back in the red label zone (E0)
To Answer Philip: All Staff but this one chap who took it upon himself to be enlightened by reading the drivers paperwork don't have a clue and no training given. Putting an ethanol fire out not so simple! Designed for complication so know your zones.
Ethanol is not a part of petrol and it is added at the distribution point where drivers are given their paper work and routes etc. If driving to an E free zone then no ethanol is added.
Finally,I believe that some of BP Ultimate is also E0 but BP will not admit to it, saying for years now that this is an evolving situation. (The Green Image) I once did ask a BP tanker driver some time ago in Suffolk, he looked down his list and said no.(Shell V Power E5 since 2008.
Hang on for that Photo.
- Log in to post comments
BP Ultimate from the middle…
BP Ultimate from the middle of England (Bedfordshire) was ethanol free two weeks ago when I bought some and tested it.
- Log in to post comments
Esso Synergy Supreme+ 99 petrol pump
Here are some pictures of the pump that delivered the Esso super unleaded tested above (4% ethanol content):
ESSO EG Gowy, TARVIN ROAD, CHESTER CH3 7HN
- Log in to post comments
E Zero
Hello Stan,
I suggest you write to Esso. Not all is E0 and the red label and E 5 sticker is a part of the confused state we live in. Political.
My Esso is as good as E0, I wouldn't use it otherwise. Bought some today.
Hull Road, Dunnington North Yorkshire
And: Leeds Road Tadcaster.
Thank you Norman for confirming what I always believed. A stupid Green image over more sales.
Stan, see any difference in the pump?...........Synergy logo not at this station.....
- Log in to post comments
Interesting . I have some…
Interesting . I have some laboratory equipment so used that to repeat the above experiment on some Synergy plus Esso fuel bought in kent a few months ago and stored in a sealed off petrol tank.(breather closed) ,result ,no ethanol. And the 63 year old tank has no rust. Could be just a coincidence ??.
- Log in to post comments
Experiment?
Rather than performing experiments on the fuel, why not just put some in your tank and ride your Norton? 1959 ES2; acquired in late August 2021; off the road for four months March - July 2022. over 5,300 miles [including two winters when it was being used frequently] since purchase. Always had E10, no fuelling issues, similar to my Commando, which hasn't travelled quite as many miles in the same period. Regular use flushes the petrol tank and brings many smiles :-)
- Log in to post comments
Colin, I find that by…
Colin, I find that by putting E10 Tesco petrol in my Norton's they ride ok,, but wear out the back tyres.
- Log in to post comments
Storage conditions can make…
Storage conditions can make a significant difference to water and corrosion in the tank. My garage has all the worst features. A cold exposed position with prevailing westerly wind brings driving rain round and under the door .An old structure with no damproofing or insulation brings condensation in winter. A washing machine ,drier, water tap ,toilet and sewerage access all add to the mix. I close off the tank vent once the machine is settled .ACf 50 on exposed chrome . Ethanol is just another hazzard to be avoided if possible.
- Log in to post comments
Neil: Esso are quite open…
Neil:
Esso are quite open about their super unleaded, see their website: https://www.esso.co.uk/en-gb/fuels
Colin:
Without being rude, although certainly a bit cheeky, I could respond - why not ride your bike instead of writing about it on forums ;)
This was in response to Neil's assertion that Esso super unleaded is ethanol free and, as we can see, in some places it very definitely is not. My point has been that you cannot make an assumption, if it matters to you then test it. Or don't waste money on Esso, just fill up at your favourite supermarket 'cos it's all the same.
- Log in to post comments
Not the same
Norman made the point that there is Ultimate E0 out there.
I also know, until further notice, that the Esso I use is E0
Doubt you will find E0 at a super market.
Just remember that ethanol is only added at the distribution point. It is added to meet an agenda and certainly not for the health of your Norton.Or humanity when one thinks of the bread that could have been made from the wheat used.
As Robert said:. Avoid Ethanol if you can. Choices are being eroded all the time. (Not just fuel, either)
- Log in to post comments
Neil Do you still get…
Neil
Do you still get hardening of the petrol pipes etc, One of my bikes is run on leaded race fuel and the pipes still suffer, indicating that part of the problem isn’t solely down to ethanol.
As I live on the Somerset/Devon Dorset Borders its difficult for me to know whether the general fuel I use is unleaded but will look out for the red labels, I can definitely confirm that my old RAV 4 runs much better on super unleaded than E10. But equally my Chainsaws and strimmers dont mind E10 in the least, nor has the fuel gone off over winter.
- Log in to post comments
Hardening of fuel pipes.
Dan,
My Commando still had the original fuel pipes when I bought it in the 80's. They were a bit yellowish and hard but perfectly serviceable. I changed these for RGM's braided stainless pipes and were fine until 2006 when they developed holes all over. I now use RGM plastic pipes but don't use ethanol. I used 4* leaded when it was available and some has been in my 16h for many years and the pet seal (Old stuff) remains perfect. (No Ethanol)
I would advise imho to test your fuel or write to Esso for your nearest E0 Supplier.
Especially in my singles, I use Red Ex synthetic lead replacement.
- Log in to post comments
Braided pipes
For whatever reason, the lining of these just disintegrate with E10 petrol. One I had lasted a whole fortnight after being fitted. Since then, I have stuck to E5 and boring but good petrol pipes.
- Log in to post comments
Braided Stainless
Gordon,
The Braided stainless lasted fine until the stealth ethanol attack in about 2006...Thanks Blair.
Was fine for about 20 odd years, Looked nice too.
Now RGM clear plastic, mind you, I don't use ethanol, but you know that......
- Log in to post comments
Tyre Wear
BP supplies Sainsbury's, last time I looked
As noted above, at least some of BP's None E10 turns out to be E0.
Looks like E10 will be forced upon you so that sales don't dry up, given E10 adverse comments?
Just another reason to increase sales (Less mpg) while taking old vehicles off the road even faster! A double whammy.......
- Log in to post comments
Thanks for your research, Stan.
You didn't day if your sample came from a pump with a RED label.? (E0)
The pump I use is based at Dunnington, near York with a RED label.
Ironically this is delivered by 'Green Energy' based in Teesside. (An Ethanol zone)
The young man who works at this filling station obtains the data from the tanker driver. Almost E0 or residue from a previous delivery, something like 0.01% from memory.
But remember, Stan that the ethanol is added or not at the distribution point. The mixing takes place on the road if added. In this case not.
So please check that the label at the pumps RED and not BLUE. Otherwise Esso has some explaining to do...