I've had an anti drain valve on my Commando for ages with no problems at all and thinking about fitting one to my 19S (1956). As the bike is used infrequently it's a nuisance to drain the crankcase before every ride, and I like the "fit and forget" nature of anti drain valves rather than shut off taps. Pros and cons?
Look here:
- Log in to post comments
anti drain valve
I saw a newish product at Kempton last year, available via their ebay shop: a valve with electrical interconnection, so can’t start engine unless valve on. two versions : magneto or coil.
from kingpincomponents.
- Log in to post comments
Enter 'oil tap with cut out…
Enter 'oil tap with cut out switch' in eBay and you'll see the tap available from Kingpin Components - it was featured in Roadholder a few months ago.
- Log in to post comments
It depends on whether you…
It depends on whether you have a magneto. The mag for the singles has no earth cut out circuit so I don't see how you could fit a cut out.
- Log in to post comments
Kingpin have a solution for that too...
They offer a points cover with a brush in contact with the points. That can then be connected to their oil tap with cut-out switch.
Definitely better than a tap with no interlock as I found when I forgot to turn the CS1 tap on. Ran fine for almost 15 miles! I was lucky, new rings and a hone got me away again although the piston is a pretty loose fit in the bore.
- Log in to post comments
Which option?
Finally got round to doing something about this but I'm looking at 2 options. Has anyone got experience of https://www.feked.com/anti-wet-sump-oil-pipe-tap-with-switch-magneto-or-coil-ignition-systems.html or https://www.kingpincomponents.co.uk/oil-taps/oil-tap-with-cutout-switch-for-coil?
Many thanks.
- Log in to post comments
Oil drain stop valve
Some time ago I saw a notice about an oil drain stop valve.
It worked by using your ignition switch key. When you shut off the engine, you put your ignition key in the valve and turned it to the "off" position. When in this position the key could not be withdrawn. So in order to start the bike you had to turn the key/oil valve on then withdraw the key to put into the ignition switch.. The idea being that with the valve closed and the key held in you couldn't start the bike.
I searched the internet and cannot now find it. Maybe someone here can steer us to it.
Good luck
Mike
- Log in to post comments
Ignition switch?
What's that, please explain??!!
- Log in to post comments
I believe he is speaking of…
I believe he is speaking of an anti drain valve that is opened and closed with your ignition switch key - when in the closed position the key cannot be removed so that there is no chance of starting with the valve closed . Sounds like a very good idea .
- Log in to post comments
ignition switch
I am fitting a Kingpin to my model 50 custom at present. They supply a relay so that the ignition connection to CDI or points can only work if that relay is switched by the tap being on, and therefore triggering the relay via an electrical wire connection. Foolproof. ( Magneto version also available.)
- Log in to post comments
Kingpin seem to be the only…
Kingpin seem to be the only supplier for a mag for a single. They have a modified end cap to allow the mag circuit to be earthed to kill it. Remember the KF mag has an earth killer circuit but Singles don't have that convenience. The Feked one should be OK if you have a KF mag but not for magdyno etc. Check Kingpin because the mag end cap modification is in addition to the valve with its switch.
- Log in to post comments
Magneto Guys....
....sell the valve as well though their supply seems to be disrupted by the lurgy.
- Log in to post comments
Wet sump is better than no sump.
A wet sump is better than no sump. A friend had an anti drain valve he fitted to his Commando between the oil tank and pump, after not usng the bike for a while he started it and checked oil return. He then got ready and rode it and it seized. I cost him a rebuild including a replacment on rod and crank regrind. He suspected that the oil below the valve had drained away while the bike was layed up, starting showed the oil returning from the sump but without waiting long enough how would he know oil was flowing from the tank. Unles you have a flow meter or indicator, pressure gauge, clear pipe lines or sme other way of knowing you have no oil flow by the time you know it is too late. The time spent draining the sump and refiling the oil tank is short compared to the time of a rebuild. The cost of oil is cheap compared to the cost of a rebuild.
- Log in to post comments
"Waiting long enough" is…
"Waiting long enough" is what you need to do - after starting my Mk 3 850 with seat off , remove oil filler cap and check oil return for at least two minutes if bike is in regular use - longer if bike has been laid up for a while. Have the Mick Hemmings anti-drain unit fitted which is based on the Velo design valve.
- Log in to post comments
I had one
fitted to my Commando and it was fine. As James suggests, Velos have always had them on the spring frame models and if you follow the instructions there should be no problems. The key is to make sure the oil pipe downstream of the valve is full of oil. Once it is there is no way air can get in unless there's a leak - and we never have them do we?
My ES2 has a tap (fitted by the previous owner) and I have a magnetic sign stuck to the advance / retard lever when it's parked up. There's no need to close the valve for anything less than a few days standing.
- Log in to post comments
Been following this thread…
Been following this thread with interest as my 1936 Model 18 has incontinence problems with the oil tank emptying into the crank. Should there be a gasket on the oil pump? In one manual I have it says put a 'minimum of jointing compound and avoid the oilways' but I can't find any reference to a gasket. What would members recommend?
- Log in to post comments
They all do that sir....
.. regardless of whether a gasket is fitted. All bikes with gear type oil pumps suffer to some extent as there can never be a complete seal unless a non return valve of some type is fitted.
I would use a thin smear of Wellseal applied with a small paintbrush but you'll still get wet sumping.
- Log in to post comments
Design feature
On the BSA unit singles, there is a one direction valve after the oil pump. As long as the springloaded ball keeps tight, no wetsumping. Works well on 50% of mine.
- Log in to post comments
Shut off valves
l have been looking at fitting a shut off valve to my bike, some of them have a very small internal bore through the valve, they are advertised to fit 8/10mm pipe but the actual bore through the valve can be 5mm which can restrict the oil flow always check before you buy.
- Log in to post comments
Anti drain valve
I was contemplating fitting the RGM spring loaded velocette type valve to my 74 850 commando mk 2 and would appreciate any info on reliability pump draining etc. i don't use bike in winter so the oil would probably drain from the line below the valve and out of the pump ?
I have read of engine blow ups on the NOC site so any info would be appreciated.
Bill Downie
- Log in to post comments
Apparently, sometimes it…
Apparently, sometimes it destroys your engine but sometimes it doesn't.
- Log in to post comments
Provided...
... the valve seals properly there's no way oil can drain below it as it would create a partial vacuum above it. By the same token, if fitting / refitting such a valve make sure the pipe downstream of the valve is full of oil.
- Log in to post comments
2 points
Yes I know this item is mostly about singles!!! Jan, if you add a relay to make this sytem work you are adding a further item to fail and you are more reliable on the battery (and charging) NOT recommended. I am happy to see this relay circuit and see if there is a better way?
If you fit an end cap to your magneto that incorporates an electrical cut out, I can supply a real ignition switch to utilise this. It isolates the battery as well.
- Log in to post comments
https://www.nortonownersclub.org/support/technical-support-common/wet-sumping-anti-drain-valves